What Are ESG Investments and Are They Worth It
ESG investing is a $40 trillion industry. But does it outperform, and does your money really make an impact? Here's the honest, data-driven answer.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. ZarWealth may earn a commission if you sign up or purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.
📚 Part of our Complete Investing Guide
ESG investing — short for Environmental, Social, and Governance — has gone from a niche concept to a $40+ trillion global industry in less than two decades. Proponents say it lets you build wealth while avoiding companies that harm the planet or exploit workers. Critics say it's marketing dressed up as investing.
So what's actually true? This guide breaks down what ESG investing is, how it works in practice, what the performance data shows, and how to decide whether it belongs in your portfolio.
What Is ESG Investing?
ESG investing uses non-financial factors to screen or evaluate investments alongside traditional financial metrics. The three pillars:
| Pillar | What It Covers | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental (E) | Climate impact, resource use, pollution | Carbon emissions, water usage, waste management |
| Social (S) | Labor practices, human rights, community | Worker safety, supply chain ethics, DEI policies |
| Governance (G) | Corporate leadership, transparency, accountability | Board independence, executive pay, shareholder rights |
ESG funds use these factors to either screen out certain companies (negative screening — no tobacco, weapons, or coal) or actively favor companies with strong ESG scores (positive screening). Some funds combine both approaches.
Types of ESG Investing
- Negative/exclusionary screening: Avoid entire industries — fossil fuels, weapons manufacturers, gambling, tobacco, alcohol. The oldest form of ethical investing.
- Positive/best-in-class screening: Invest in companies with the best ESG scores within each sector, including energy companies that rank highly on environmental practices relative to peers.
- ESG integration: Use ESG data as one factor among many in traditional financial analysis. Many large institutional investors do this without calling it "ESG investing."
- Impact investing: Invest specifically to generate measurable positive outcomes — clean energy projects, affordable housing, microfinance. More common in private markets.
- Shareholder activism: Buy shares in companies to vote on ESG-related resolutions and push for change from within.
Popular ESG ETFs
The easiest way to invest in ESG is through ETFs that do the screening for you:
| ETF | Focus | Expense Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| ESGV (Vanguard) | US ESG with exclusions | 0.09% |
| ESGU (iShares) | MSCI USA ESG optimized | 0.15% |
| SUSA (iShares) | MSCI USA ESG select | 0.25% |
| ICLN (iShares) | Clean energy global | 0.40% |
| VFTAX (Vanguard) | ESG US stock fund (mutual) | 0.14% |
For context on how sector exposure affects returns, see our guide on sector investing and whether it's worth it — ESG funds often have significant sector tilts toward tech and healthcare.
Does ESG Investing Actually Perform?
This is where the debate gets heated. Here's what the data shows:
The Case For: ESG Has Kept Up
Many ESG funds have performed comparably to the broader market over the past decade. During the 2020 crash and recovery, ESG funds generally held up better than traditional indexes, partly because they were underweight in energy stocks (which crashed hard) and overweight in tech (which surged).
The Case Against: Survivorship Bias and Concentration
Critics point out that ESG's recent outperformance may reflect sector tailwinds (overweight tech, underweight energy) rather than ESG factors themselves. In 2022, when energy stocks surged and tech crashed, most ESG funds significantly underperformed. Over longer time horizons, the evidence for ESG outperformance is mixed at best.
There's also the "greenwashing" problem — companies spend heavily on ESG ratings and disclosures without meaningfully changing practices. Many ESG funds include Apple, Microsoft, and Amazon despite their controversial environmental and labor records.
The Greenwashing Problem
ESG ratings are not standardized. A company rated highly by MSCI might score poorly with Sustainalytics or Bloomberg — different agencies use different methodologies, weighting factors, and data sources. Tesla has been excluded from some ESG indexes for labor and governance issues despite being an electric vehicle company. ExxonMobil has been included in some ESG funds due to strong governance scores.
This inconsistency means "ESG fund" doesn't automatically mean what investors think it means. Always look inside the fund's holdings before assuming it aligns with your values.
Alternative: Real-Asset Impact Investing
For investors who want their money to have tangible environmental impact, alternative assets can be worth exploring. Platforms like FarmTogether let accredited investors fund US farmland operations — providing food supply infrastructure while generating returns from land appreciation and crop income. It's a different angle on values-aligned investing than ESG stock funds.
Is ESG Investing Right For You?
Here's an honest framework:
- If values alignment matters most to you: ESG funds let you exclude industries you find objectionable. Even if performance is similar, sleeping well at night has value.
- If returns are your primary goal: The evidence doesn't support a persistent return advantage from ESG. A low-cost total market index fund likely serves you better.
- If you want both: Consider a "core + tilt" approach — 80% total market index, 20% ESG or clean energy tilt. You get broad market returns with some values alignment.
- If you care about impact: Buying public company shares doesn't directly fund those companies. For real impact, consider impact bonds, community development loans, or private impact funds.
For an evidence-based framework for building a long-term portfolio regardless of ESG preferences, see our guide on building a dividend portfolio from scratch.
A Simple Path to Wealth by JL Collins — a clear-eyed guide to building wealth through simple indexing, with a perspective on why complexity (including ESG complexity) often works against the investor.
The Little Book of Common Sense Investing by John C. Bogle — the classic case for low-cost, whole-market investing that forms the bedrock against which any ESG strategy should be evaluated.
Both are available on Audible — try it free for 30 days and get your first audiobook included.
Want the full picture? This article is part of our Complete Investing Guide — covering everything from ETF selection and stock valuation to socially responsible investing and portfolio construction.
📥 Free download: The 10-Step Financial Independence Checklist
The exact roadmap I followed to build my financial foundation. 11 pages, professionally designed, free with email signup — no credit card, unsubscribe anytime.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. ZarWealth may earn a commission if you sign up through our links, at no extra cost to you.
